Jay Dobyns Loses Again

March 9, 2016

All Posts, News

Jay Dobyns Loses Again

Fame whore Jay Dobyns’ eight-year-long, mostly secret lawsuit against the ATF seems about to actually end. In anticipation of that end, Dobyns told the Dobyns-friendly Arizona Republic that he wasn’t going to get richer because U.S. Court of Federal Claims Chief Judge Patricia Campbell-Smith was incompetent.

Dobyns was an agent with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives who became famous for hanging around with and prospecting the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club in Arizona from early 2002 through July 2003. The very flawed and corrupt infiltration in which he participated was later called “Operation Black Biscuit.” The name was coined on the set of the defunct Fox reality series America’s Most Wanted. The ATF made Dobyns a celebrity and created a monster. Dobyns wrote a book about his biker adventures titled No Angel: My Harrowing Undercover Journey To The Inner Circle Of The Hells Angels and was the subject of two more.


He soon annoyed his ATF supervisors who described Dobyns as “broken” and “unfit for duty.” Dobyns complained that he was threatened with retaliation by the Hells Angels and the ATF was doing nothing to protect him. He sued the Bureau and reached a $373,000 settlement in September 2007. Someone fire bombed his Tucson home in August 2008. Dobyns claimed the fire was a murder attempt that resulted from the ATF’s refusal to protect him. The ATF thought Dobyns set the fire himself and questioned his sanity. Dobyns then filed his current suit against the Bureau in October 2008. The ATF countersued for the royalties from Dobyns book.

It has been frequently reported that the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club was responsible for the fire at Dobyns home but Dobyns told The Aging Rebel “I have never said to anyone publicly or privately that the Hells Angels burned my house down. Find where I have. I have said that ATF let someone get away with it and in the process also get away with attempting to murder my family. Believe it or not but my beef is not with the Hells Angels. They are in my rear view mirror. My beef is with ATF.”

In August 2014, after a month long secret trial, Federal District Judge Francis M. Allegra ruled that the ATF owed Dobyns $173,000, which was his yearly salary in 2007. Dobyns had sought $7.2 million for pain, suffering and emotional distress and an additional $10 million for “economic damages.”

Unfair Lawyers

Allegra also suspected that the ATF’s lawyers had treated Dobyns unfairly during the long suit. Allegra ordered an investigation into the conduct of the government attorneys and in anticipation that the report would find those attorneys guilty of misconduct, Dobyns filed a motion for relief.

A week ago Judge Campbell-Smith, who now presides over the case, accepted the investigator’s report and overruled Dobyns motion. Although her decision, like most of the case, remains sealed the acceptance and ruling indicate she has ruled against Dobyns. Dobyns may yet find a way to continue his suit but he didn’t sound like it in comments published today in the Republic.

“I think she put her competence – or incompetence – on display,” Dobyns said about the judge. “Is it smart for Jay Dobyns, as a plaintiff before that court, to say that? Probably not, but I don’t care anymore. I don’t care if I offend her. I think her response was incomplete.”

Whether Dobyns likes it or not, the judge’s ruling may mean that his personal, bespoken spotlight is finally starting to dim.

, , ,

68 Responses to “Jay Dobyns Loses Again”

  1. March 11th Says:

    @ Shovelhead

    I could tell you a story that would blow your mind. My opinion is based giving all and getting fucked over. Betrayal is unforgivable. Having said that everything I now do is 1st dynamic driven.

  2. Shovelhead Says:

    March 11th
    You need to find a better crowd to hang around, there’s plenty of 1%ers out there who would die for their Brother. I know times have changed and there’s a lot of fakes out there. But there’s also a lot of Brothers sitting in some Hell Hole because they wouldn’t rat out their Brothers. No deals, no giving anyone up for a get out of jail free card. They sit proud, locked up, but they can hold their head high.

    Takes a special kind of scum sucking pig like Dobyns to not only rat out people he made friends with, met their families, men who had his back. But he also lied trying to screw them. Was all this to save American lives? keep children safe? No! Just to make himself look like a Hero.
    He’s as low as Child molesters and rapists in my book. You’ll get yours Dobyns you coward piece of shit.

  3. March 11th Says:

    Fuck Jay but the statement stands.

  4. chromedome Says:

    March 11 is a bitch. Fuck Gay dobyns


  5. RtC Says:

    That should have been SARCASTIC! (Damn, gettin’ old ain’t for sissies OR literates!)

  6. RtC Says:

    “March 11th, was that sarcisstic?(sp?) Or are you butt-buddies with “Th’Douche”?! Otherwise known as the whiny-assed sniveling POS who’s gonna get
    what he gave?!

  7. March 11th Says:

    Jay really? Come on man! Do you really have that much faith in humans? There is no loyalty. There is no code of honor. Everyone eats their young. Its all bullshit. There ain’t a motherfucker on this planet that wouldn’t trick bag a brother or a stranger for the right motivation.

    Only a fool believes otherwise.

  8. Nuke n' Pave Dave Says:

    Dobyns, the beard perm doesn’t do a thing for you. Well, unless you count the faggot meat market bars and the way you can tickle the boys there with it…

  9. Ken the citizen Says:

    jay Douchebag dobyns,
    Neither side respects a snitch, ever.
    @ Wino Enzed, thats some funny shit

    Respects to those who deserve it.


  10. Phuquehed Says:

    @Fr. Abraham – Him burning up in a raging wildfire is too iffy…he still might survive and then we’d have to pay for him being on disability.

    No, better the air-wasting dipshit find himself out of gas in an MS-13 owned neighborhood one night. It’s guaranteed the useless turd will never be seen or heard of again and the pigs won’t look too hard since that’s a *real* “gang”.

  11. Fr. Abraham Says:

    @Gooch: You hit that nail squarely on the head, sir. This douchebag is crying because the people who paid him to screw people is now screwing him, as if he somehow didn’t know the feds weren’t in business to do anything other than screw people.

    I hope this guy finds himself a raging wildfire and decides to roll around in it.

    -Fr. Abraham

  12. Austin Says:

    IronRider Says:

    What Dobbins fails to understand is that he was and is disposable

    Nailed It.

    @Meh re: “Making a career of “behold muh brave snitching” ”

  13. dogbreath Says:

    The beard has got to be tied in with his “Bird” persona, some strange attempt to emulate the bright plumage male birds display to instill lust in the female or awe/fear in his competitor. To see his odd preening for the camera further reinforces the impression. Hey Jaybird? It’s not working.

  14. rollinnorth Says:

    My, my, Jay Dobyns calls himself a whistleblower. Jay Dobyns called himself a member of the 81, also. Jay Dobyns has called himself many things, except what he is: a lying $ack of $#!t.
    Time for him to crawl back under his rock and stay there.

    Respect, to those…

  15. Potmetal Says:

    @Meh, Very clearly stated truth. Hope it isnt copyrighted by you, because I want to use those 2 paragraphs to illustrate something ive been trying to articulate to my sons (and failing at).

    Thank you for posting it the way you did.


  16. Meh Says:

    Even a blind pig finds an acorn now and then. F&F may fall into that category.

    A rat is still a rat and if you choose a side you’d wisely be fine with whatever laws that side may break. That’s inherently part of taking sides in human conflict. In for a penny, in for a pound. IMO most humans are situational outlaws. We pick laws we like, obey most we don’t like because disobedience is inconvenient, and break some (small or large) as calculated risks.

    If you choose MULTIPLE sides then snitch on ALL of them (no matter the veracity of said snitching) that suggests you are irrational. Making a career of “behold muh brave snitching” is a great way to wipe out potential support leaving you alone with your twisted self and your party store chin whiskers.

  17. IronRider Says:

    What Dobbins fails to understand is that he was and is disposable. Nothing more than that. The ATF and it’s law enforcement pals used Dobbins to do a task which was get close to the HA.

    Sure Dobbins got a pat on the ass and his ego stroked and what ever commendations they threw his way for his alleged awesome job and of course the ATF and USDOJ sang Dobbins praises and put on a full court press to anyone in the media how this was a serious blow to the HA and much damage has been done and bla bla bla, the usual rhetoric that’s heard anytime an MC can be brought up as the boogeyman.

    Dobbins seems to think he is owed more than what he has already received from the ATF and the courts and feels abandoned by the ATF. So has Dobbins been abandoned by the ATF? You bet your ass he has, and really who didnt see that coming? Dobbins apparently.

    Hey Jay, a little tip to you: Law Enforcement no matter what branch or entity will use their informants/agents/snitches to get what they want and use it to get someone charged or indicted, then get them into court… get said informants/agents/snitches to testify and then once they have used said informants/agents/snitches then it’s thanks and dont let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.

    You got used Jay, just like any informants/agents/snitches do. You served your purpose to them and now you are of no use to them, they dont want you around them, they dont want to extend further help, and they sure as fuck dont want to keep paying you. You got played Jay and the funny thing is you have probably seen this happen to other informants/agents/snitches as well.

    Did you really believe Jay that the pedestal that the ATF (and to some degree you) were on was never going to come down? That the ATF and friends were going to make you a rock star after the op was over? You are and were disposable, they used you, like they do with others. They got what they wanted from you and you serve no purpose to them afterwards. It’s simple Jay, they fucked you and you took it like a champ, you thought it would be forever when really it was just a fling and meant nothing to them.

    So Jay you can keep writing books and keep your mug on tv and whine and pout about how life is unfair and everyone is doing you wrong, but honestly man, just admit to yourself that you got played and you were disposable and they are done with you. Maybe you ought to call up George Christie and you can cry on one another’s shoulder about how wronged you both were.

    Maybe you and george can be besties and go bowling together, go for a beer after and stroke one another bruised ego’s. It’s a match made in heaven. But really Jay, I would say man up and take it that you got played, but we both know that won’t happen. So Jay just STFU, quit whining and go on with your life in the shadows or basement or under that rock you were hiding and get on with your life. Your 15 minutes were up long ago, just ask George, he can tell you all about that.

  18. Whitepride Says:

    Jay take this advice. Drugs are bad Mmmkay

  19. Mark Matis Says:

    So you don’t believe he spilled the beans on the F&F treason, rollinnorth?

    Maybe you could pass that along to David Codrea at:

    or Mike Vanderboegh at:

    But then surely F&F was nothing more than a figment of Dobyn’s imagination all along.

  20. Potmetal Says:

    Woah, holy fuck!!! That thing on his face?!?!?! Nuke that shit from orbit, and do it rapidly!

    Thought he was sorry before, but now after seeing that, I need the brain bleach. What a utter waste.

  21. Meh Says:

    Beard looks fake to hide his identity, as if anyone gave a shit. He should have used a colored condom over his head.

    Sounds like he believes his own bullshit which means he’ll keep poking the government bear with predictable results. :)

  22. Fuck You Jay Says:

    Met this idiot in SFV. Didn’t trust him then. Sure wouldn’t trust him now.

  23. shootemall Says:

    So he got a raw deal and the judge didn’t go his way? Wow, never heard of that happening before. He should join Isis now. He has the beard for it.

  24. Jim666 Says:

    Fuck off Shitbird.

  25. Tommy Says:

    Cant stand this idiot

  26. 605/Reaper Says:

    Somebody will tap on his shoulder one day.

  27. Steel Says:

    ATF cut him loose as soon as he had no more use to them. HA proves that he is a liar and a con man. Now he whines about it constantly. Don’t go away mad Dobyns, just go away.



  28. PJ Says:

    I’m amused his quote at the end of the article has him referring to himself in the 3rd person…

    “I think she put her competence – or incompetence – on display,” Dobyns said about the judge. “Is it smart for Jay Dobyns, as a plaintiff before that court, to say that? Probably not, but I don’t care anymore. I don’t care if I offend her. I think her response was incomplete.”

  29. englishyank Says:

    the fuck is going on with his beard? WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING WITH HIS BEARD?! The judge probably thought exactly the same thing, no words can be heard, just “WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON WITH THAT BEARD?!”

    Christ he must have some amount of time on his hands to think that was a good idea.


  30. old & stoned Says:

    it’s obvious every time he opens his mouth he cooked his brain like a true speed freak, permanently re-wired. the only real losers here are the taxpayers financing this shitstain’s midlife crisis.

  31. Lost Cause Says:

    He looks like a caricature of Neptune (minus the trident and king-of-the-sea cool factor). Drive yourself out in the desert, eat a bullet, and let the buzzards choke on your arrogance. Really, no one will even notice you’re gone.

  32. rollinnorth Says:

    Fast and Furious, eh? “Agent Dobyns” knows where Jimmy Hoffa is, too, right?
    Sonny Barger said it best, “Dobyns is a liar.”


  33. FF Says:

    “Harrowing journey”


  34. FXR Says:

    wtf is that guy on? Can anti-depressants do that?

  35. Googs Says:

    His beard looks like Davey Jones tentacle chin in Pirates of the Caribbean….whatta bum.

  36. Phuquehed Says:

    A rat growing a little faggy curlyqued cum napkin on his chin whining about a judge not doing the right thing. Welcome to the real world, Jay, you fucking waste of air.

  37. oregonloner Says:

    Oh no! how will he pay for his beardacures, and without millions his mouth vagina may close, sad day for all fed snitches.

  38. Mark Matis Says:

    It was Agent Dobyns who exposed Fast and Furious. But then surely BATFE would NEVER do anything such as he claimed in retaliation. After all, they are such honorable men and women. BATFE Agent Hop[e McAllister from their Phoenix Field Division calling Border Patrol Agent Terry’s murder “collateral damage” must have been a simple misunderstanding…

  39. Boilerfrosty Says:

    I’ve found that the best way to deal with police is to not deal with them in the first place. Plus it is good for your health and the health of your loved one’s.

  40. Paladin Says:

    It’s hard to get traction when the road one chooses to travel is paved with deceit and slim.


  41. popeye Says:

    Your 15 minutes are up jay no one likes you .

  42. gooch Says:

    <zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz# ~ Damn had to sit back with a smoke and think on this. Jay trusted a bunch of feds, who hired him to fuck over people. Now he's crying and whining about them fucking him over. "what goes around comes around" its like the saying "never get a blowjob from a pit bull" Did Jay really think the feds would keep blowing him, without eventually biting that shit off? Seems like Jay may have been wise to think things through before he got on the train.

    ~ Gooch

  43. Ziocles Says:

    Authorities failed to convict any of the 16 defendants on the key charge of racketeering, or running a criminal enterprise.

    • Half of those indicted were given plea deals on lesser offenses.

    • Federal charges against five others were dismissed.

    • Under the indictment, most of the bikers faced possible life terms. As a result of plea deals, none will serve more than five years in federal prison.

  44. WheresMyBoots Says:

    Wow, ‘Big Red Friday’ looks like some classic thespian work there. Yikes.
    Read all three books, and one thing derived from that: Jay, ah…everybody else’s versions are a little different.
    Some of the guys you ‘infiltrated’ -specifically the one you claimed was your ‘sponsor’ and who you clearly idolized- were on t.v. (can’t remember which program) and seemed to find you pretty amusing.
    Oh, and the cut draped over your shoulders? ‘Like a knight’s robe.’ Saw the video from your hidden cameras: nobody wearing cuts there dude. Not one cut. Mr. Barger explained in another program why that was: the men came to see you in a car.

  45. Ziocles Says:

    Some info on his little operation:

    Authorities failed to convict any of the 16 defendants on the key charge of racketeering, or running a criminal enterprise.

    • Half of those indicted were given plea deals on lesser offenses.

    • Federal charges against five others were dismissed.

    • Under the indictment, most of the bikers faced possible life terms. As a result of plea deals, none will serve more than five years in federal prison.

  46. Wino Enzed Says:

    Next thing he will be joining the Iron Order ( under cover of course lol)

  47. Ziocles Says:

    Jesus, the Go T is ridiculous. This guy looks like a shitty cartoon character.I love how he mentions his work with the HA and how ” it ended with mass arrests and indictments” managed to skip over how many convictions though…..

  48. swampy Says:

    Dobyns can always have someone set his house on fire again. That should get him another month or two of attention. Fuck him.

  49. NOS4A2 Says:

    You are such a dickweed.

  50. Shyster Says:

    We’re on Earth maybe 75 – 90 years if we are lucky. This fucken tweeker addict loser has managed to be a piece of shit most of those years. Take yourself out of the gene pool.


Leave a Reply